|
|
Type of Business
|
Number of Owners
|
How to form
|
Level of personal liability
|
Tax consequences
|
Ability to Transfer ownership
|
|
Sole
Proprietorship
|
One
|
Just do it
|
Unlimited
|
Owner pays
|
Totally transferable
|
|
Partnership
|
Two of more
|
Verbal or written agreement
|
Unlimited for general partners; limited partners can lose up to the amount they've invested
|
Individual partners must pay
|
May need consent of other partners
|
|
"C"
Corporation
|
Unlimited
|
follow rules set by state law
|
Only the amount you've invested
|
Corporation pays on earnings; shareholders pay on dividends
|
Totally transferable
|
|
"S"
Corporation
|
Up to thirty-five, must be U.S. citizens or residents
|
Follow rules set by state law and the Internal Revenue Service
|
Only the amount you've invested
|
Individual shareholders pay
|
May be limited in order to preserve "S" status
|
|
Limited-Liability
Corporation
|
Two or more
|
Follow rules set by state law
|
Only the amount you've invested
|
Individual owners pay
|
Generally need consent of all owners
|
|
A sole proprietorship is the most common
form of business organization. A sole
proprietor is fully and personally liable for
all the obligations (including debts) of the
business. Of course, the sole proprietor is also
entitled to all of the business's profits and
exercises complete managerial
control.
Generally, the earnings of the sole
proprietorship itself are not subject to income
tax, although some state and local governments
do impose an unincorporated business tax on
profits. Income and losses, however, must be
included in the owner's personal tax returns.
The sole proprietorship terminates on its
owner's death or retirement.
A sole proprietor is not ordinarily
required to file any documents with the state
unless it is doing business under an "assumed"
or "fictitious" name -- that is, a name other
than the real name of its owner. In that case,
the owner must usually file a "doing business
as" or "d/b/a" certificate. This typically gets
filed in the county or with the secretary of
state of the state in which the business is
located, and a filing fee is often
required.
Return to Table of Contents
for this guide | Return
to index of all guides | Return to the top of this page
In its most basic form, a partnership is
an association of two or more people who agree
to share in the profits and losses of a business
venture.
A partnership can usually be formed
without paying any fees or filing any papers,
except for the "d/b/a" certificate. In fact,
you're not legally required to put a partnership
agreement in writing, although it is highly
recommended, especially if you're starting a
venture with several partners who are investing
different amounts of money.
Typically, when you form a partnership,
it is done in the spirit of optimism and
success. Unfortunately, conflicts often arise.
By putting your agreement in writing, you can
help avoid potential conflicts at the outset.
Some of the topics a partnership agreement might include are:
- Partners' voting rights and management
responsibilities
- The allocation of profits and losses
among the partners
- Partners' rights to transfer or sell
their interests in the partnership
- The circumstances under which the
partnership may terminate
- Means for settling disputes among the
partners In the absence of a partnership
agreement, your state's partnership law will
determine how these matters are resolved -- and
you may not like the result. If there is a
significant amount of money involved in your
partnership venture, you should consult a lawyer
to help you work out the terms of your
agreement.
What are the Advantages of a Partnership?
A key advantage of a partnership is that
no taxes are paid by the partnership itself.
Although a federal income tax return must be
filed by the partnership with the IRS, it is for
informational purposes only. Profits or losses
are "passed through" directly to the partners,
who report them on their individual
returns.
Also, because filing requirements are
minimal, partnerships can be created relatively
inexpensively. One of the main disadvantages of
a partnership involves liability -- each partner
is personally liable for the obligations of the
business. This means that someone who sues the
partnership can also sue and recover from each
individual partner. If the partnership owes
money, each partner can be held liable for the
amount of the entire debt.
So, when you enter into a partnership
agreement, not only is your investment in the
business at stake, but all of your other
personal assets may be at risk as well. In
addition, any one partner can enter into a
contract for which that partner and all of the
other partners will be responsible. So, if
your partner in That's The Way The Cookie
Crumbles makes a deal to buy $100,000 worth of
chocolate chips, you, your partner and your
partnership business will be liable for meeting
the $100,000 obligation incurred, even if the
partnership had already decided to discontinue
the chocolate chip cookie line.
Another disadvantage of a partnership is
that partners aren't always free to come and go.
If you want to sell your interest in a
partnership, you usually need the consent of all
the other partners. If you leave without their
approval, you may forfeit your partnership
investment. You should remember, though, that
many of these disadvantages can be anticipated
and addressed in a partnership agreement. That's
a good reason for having one.
What is a Limited Partnership?
A limited partnership has two kinds of
partners: general and limited. The rights
and obligations of a general partner are very
similar to those of a partner in a regular
partnership. A general partner has the right to
participate in the management of the partnership
and has unlimited personal liability for its
debts. A limited partner, on the other hand, is
personally liable for the debts of the
partnership only to the extent of his or her
investment in it and has little, if any, voice
in its management.
You might want to form a limited
partnership if you have financial backers for
your partnership venture who do not want to be
involved in running it. As a matter of fact,
limited partners who become actively involved in
the management of the partnership run the risk
of losing their limited personal liability.
While a regular partnership can be
entered into rather informally, a limited
partnership is created only when it is formally
registered with the state in which the
partnership proposes to do business. To
register, you must file a "certificate of
limited partnership," which provides certain
information required by law regarding the
partners and the partnership.
If you are thinking about forming a
limited partnership you should consult an
attorney. Not only should you have help
preparing your written agreement, but you also
may have to comply with certain federal and
state securities laws intended to protect
investors from fraud.
When you sell interests in a limited
partnership, or even offer to sell them, you may
be required to file certain documents, such as a
financial statement or a prospectus. These
documents generally should be prepared with the
assistance of an attorney. A failure to make the
required disclosures could result in steep fines
and even criminal penalties.
Return to Table of Contents
for this guide | Return
to index of all guides | Return to the top of this page
A corporation is an independent entity
that is usually created to conduct a business. A
corporation is like an individual. It can:
- Sue or be sued
- Borrow money
- Pay taxes
- Apply for business licenses in its own
name
- Enter into contracts
- Assume liabilities
A corporation can do all of these things
under its own name, without making the
individual owners and investors, known as
shareholders, liable. The shareholders must
always keep in mind, however, that they and the
corporation are separate entities, and that they
must treat the corporation as such in order to
take advantages of its benefits. This rule
applies even when the corporation has only one
shareholder.
What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of a Corporation?
One significant advantage of the
corporate structure is that the shareholders are
usually protected from personal liability. Of
course, any shares you own are vulnerable if the
corporation has excessive debt or goes bankrupt.
Still, you will be liable only to the extent of
your investment in the corporation; your assets
beyond that ordinarily will be shielded.
Another advantage is that, unlike a partnership,
you are free to sell your interest (shares) in a
corporation.
Unlike a sole proprietorship or a
partnership, a corporation's life span is
usually perpetual, even when there is only one
shareholder. If you intend for your corporation
to grow beyond your lifetime, the fact that it
can "outlive" you and that your shares are
transferable can be very helpful in getting
long-term financing as your business
grows.
The major disadvantages of a corporation
are the expenses of startup and the meticulous
record keeping required to comply with the many
formalities of state laws. A failure to make
filings and payments on time carries penalties.
In addition, all-important corporate decisions
must be approved by the board of directors, and
sometimes may require the involvement of an
attorney.
Are There Different Kinds of Corporations?
Yes, there are several types. These
include charitable (not-for-profit) corporations
and professional (P.C.) corporations.
Professional corporations are formed by certain
professionals who are required to be licensed in
order to render their services. Attorneys and
physicians typically use this
structure.
For most small businesses, though, there
are basically two types of corporations: the "C
corporation and the "S" corporation. A "C"
corporation may have an unlimited number of
shareholders. An "S" corporation, on the other
hand, can have no more than 35 shareholders, all
of whom must be U.S. citizens or residents.
The key difference lies in the way the
two types of corporations are taxed: "C"
corporation shareholders are taxed twice at the
federal level. First, the corporation pays tax
on its earnings, and then the shareholders pay
tax on any dividends they received. "S"
corporation shareholders, on the other hand, are
taxed only once, because the corporation pays no
tax on earnings.
As with a partnership, profits or losses
of an "S" corporation are passed through to the
shareholders to be reported on their personal
tax returns in proportion to their ownership
interests in the corporation. You should
note, however, that the "S" corporation
shareholders are taxed on the corporation's
earnings whether or not a dividend is actually
paid.
To qualify as an "S" corporation, a
corporation with 35 shareholders or less must
file a special form with the IRS requesting to
be treated as an "S" corporation. In addition,
about two-thirds of all states recognize
"S" corporations for state tax purposes. You
must file a form with your state's tax authority
to qualify. You should consult with your tax
advisor to determine your corporation's
eligibility for treatment as an "S" corporation
and to ensure that you comply with IRS and state
law requirements once your corporation
qualifies.
What is the Difference Between a "Publicly Held" and a "Closely Held" Corporation?
It's a key distinction between types of corporations.
A "publicly held" company is one that
typically either has shares that trade on a
recognized exchange (for example, the New York
Stock Exchange), or has assets of more than $5
million and has a class of stock held by 500 or
more people. Publicly held corporations are
regulated by both state agencies and the federal
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) which
require that they make regular "disclosures" to
shareholders regarding the corporation's assets
and liabilities. The purpose of these
disclosures is to enable the investing public to
make informed decisions when considering the
purchase of the corporation's
securities.
A "closely held" or "privately held"
corporation usually has a relatively small
number of shareholders, no shares of stock
available for public purchase, and active
participation by many of the shareholders in the
management of the corporation.
Small businesses are closely held
companies and are not required to make the same
types of disclosures. As a small business owner,
however, you must keep in mind that you and your
corporation must still comply with the relevant
anti-fraud provisions of both the laws of your
state and the SEC.
You should consult with an attorney about
your responsibilities and potential liability
under these laws, particularly if you intend to
offer or sell interests in your business to the
investing public.
How is a Corporation Run?
Major business decisions for a
corporation are made by its board of directors,
which is elected by the shareholders. The
day-to-day responsibility for running the
corporation is typically handled by its
officers. The corporation's by-laws (its rules
and regulations), which are written at the time
of incorporation (when the company is formed),
specify the number and respective duties of
directors and officers. Traditionally, state
statutes have required all corporations to have
certain officers, including:
- A president
- At least one vice president
- A secretary (the officer who keeps the
corporate minutes and records)
- A treasurer
In this traditional corporate form, one
person can hold any two offices -- except for
the offices of secretary and president --
unless the corporation has only one shareholder.
A corporation's officers are usually elected by
the board of directors. The directors have the
power to elect anyone they wish, including
themselves or family members. The board also has
the power to fire corporate officers.
Members of the board of directors as well
as corporate officers have what is known as a
"fiduciary duty" to the corporation. This means
that they have an obligation to protect the
shareholders' interests rather than their own
personal interests. This is true even when the
board member or officer is a shareholder. This
fiduciary duty requires all board members and
officers to:
- Act with honesty, good faith and
diligence
- Act solely for the benefit of the
corporation
- Use their best business judgment in
making decisions affecting the corporation.
These are essentially the same guidelines
that a reasonable person uses when running a
business. Corporate officers and directors are
generally not held personally liable for the
success or failure of a corporation's actions
unless they have violated these
guidelines. For example, an officer who
commits fraud using the corporation's assets
could be held liable for any losses incurred by
the shareholders.
What Are the Rights of the Shareholders?
Although the shareholders are the owners
of a corporation, their role in management is
usually limited, unless the business venture is
relatively small. Shareholders of large or small
companies can, however, influence the conduct of
business in a number of ways. For example,
shareholders have the power to:
- Elect and remove directors
- Influence the allocation of power by
making changes to the corporation's
"articles of incorporation" (the document under
which the corporation is formed)
- Approve or disapprove such fundamental
changes as a merger, a sale of substantial
assets, or the dissolution of, the corporation.
The more shares a person holds, of
course, the more influential his or her vote
will be, since each share ordinarily gets one
vote.
How Do You Incorporate?
The rules for incorporating vary from
state to state. Generally, however, you must
file articles of incorporation with the
secretary of state of the state in which you are
incorporating, and pay a filing fee.
The information in the articles of incorporation usually includes:
- The name of the corporation and its
principal address
- The general purpose of the
corporation--for example, "to conduct lawful
business" or "to make a lawful profit"
- The number and types of shares of stock
authorized to be issued and the rights of each
type (for example, voting and any dividend
rights)
- How long the corporation will exist (it
can be perpetual)
- The names and addresses of the members of
the initial board of directors
- The names and addresses of the
"incorporators" who prepared the articles.
Your filing date will be the date of
receipt in the secretary's office; and, if it is
approved, your corporation will be considered to
have been formed on that date.
Is a Lawyer Necessary?
No, but it is advisable to consult one.
While there are a number of companies that can
help you form your corporation, such as The
Company Corporation, if there is any problem
with your filing, the corporate structure could
be jeopardized, and you could end up with a
liability that you did not expect.
Are There Other Steps Necessary to Complete the Incorporation Process?
Yes. Although your business is officially
incorporated on the date of acceptance of your
filing in the secretary of state's office,
several additional steps must be taken to get
your corporation up and running.
First, the initial board of directors or
the incorporators (depending on the laws of your
state) must adopt by-laws: the procedural rules
and regulations that govern how the corporation
is run. The by-laws generally cover the
following considerations:
- Meetings of officers, directors and
shareholders, including requirements on the
number of members who must be present at a
meeting in order to conduct business, the
process of notifying people of meetings, and
other important developments
- Number, tenure and qualifications of
officers and directors
- Procedural rules relating to the approval
of contracts, loans, checks and deposits
- Formalities regarding share certificates,
share transfers and the corporate seal, which is
used to authenticate the corporation's legal
documents
- Procedures for amending the by-laws.
Unlike the articles of incorporation, the
corporation's by-laws do not have to be filed
with the secretary of state. After the by-laws
have been adopted, the following actions are
taken by the board:
- The officers of the corporation are
elected
- The corporate seal and form of share
certificate are adopted
- Shares are issued, provided that proper
payment has been received
- Certain officers are authorized to open
the corporation's bank accounts and to sign
checks on its behalf
- If appropriate, the "election" of "S"
corporation status is authorized.
Upon the adoption of these resolutions,
the corporation is usually in business. Some
states may require you to file additional
documents, such as your employee identification
numbers, before the corporation is considered up
and running.
Where Should You Incorporate?
The general rule of thumb for the small
business owner is to incorporate in the state in
which he or she intends to operate the business.
Many business owners seem to have a
preconceived notion that Delaware is the most
desirable incorporation choice. For some
companies, such as those contemplating a "public
offering" of their shares, Delaware may still be
a good choice because its law is particularly
well developed.
Because individual business circumstances
vary, you should carefully consider which state
in which to incorporate. In making your
decision, you should bear in mind that states
generally impose a tax (commonly known as a
"franchise" tax) on corporations that are either
incorporated under their laws or do business
within their borders. So, if your business is
incorporated in one state but headquartered in
another, it may be subject to tax in both
states.
Return to Table of Contents
for this guide | Return
to index of all guides | Return to the top of this page
A limited liability company is a business
structure which is best described as a "hybrid"
between a partnership and a corporation in that
it gives its owners the best of both worlds: (1)
a "pass through" of all profits and losses to
the owners without taxation of the entity
itself, as in a partnership, and (2) a shield
from personal liability, as in a
corporation.
An "S" corporation and a limited
partnership also offer these advantages. But,
unlike an "S" corporation, a limited liability
"company" is actually a non-corporate entity.
State laws, which would require a board of
directors and officers and would dictate
adoption of by-laws, do not apply.
Also, unlike the limited partner in a
limited partnership, a member of a limited
liability company may participate actively in
its management without risking loss of the
limitation on personal liability. The
limited liability company, then, offers a great
deal of flexibility. It is preferred primarily
by owners of small, but relatively riskier,
ventures who seek an active management role and
limited liability.
How is a Limited Liability Company Formed?
Although a limited liability company is
free from the restrictions of the corporate
form, its formation and general manner of
operation are governed by state law. The entity
may be formed by two or more persons who must
file with the secretary of state of the state in
which the enterprise is to be established its
articles of organization, and pay a filing fee.
Because the powers of the limited
liability company are very similar to those of a
corporation, the provisions of its articles of
organization, which are also prescribed by law,
are quite similar to those of the articles of
incorporation of a corporation.
The limited liability company comes into
existence when the secretary of state issues a
"certificate of organization." The duration of a
limited liability company is limited to 30
years. Unlike a corporation, the limited
liability company has no by-laws.
The consensus of its members regarding
managerial and related issues are set forth in
an operating agreement, which is analogous to
the "shareholders agreement" among the owners of
a corporation. In fact, state laws typically
require that the limited liability company have
an operating agreement. It is advisable to
consult a lawyer when organizing a limited
liability company.
Return to Table of Contents
for this guide | Return
to index of all guides | Return to the top of this page
A franchise is a business relationship in
which an owner (the franchisor) licenses others
(the franchisees) to operate outlets using
business concepts, property, trademarks and
trade names owned by the franchisor. Your local
McDonald's is probably operated as a franchise.
Franchise relationships are regulated by each
state and by the Federal Trade Commission and
are often quite complex.
A contract known as a franchise agreement
should spell out the details of each particular
venture. The franchisor often provides the
initial capital for the franchise and, in turn,
typically takes in a larger share of future
profits. In addition, a franchisor usually
provides:
- A proven business concept
- Name recognition
- Business know-how
- Experience
- Advertising support
The franchisee provides:
- Supplemental capital
- The effort to make the business concept
work
The franchisor and the franchisee both
share in the risks and returns of the business,
although each agreement is structured
differently. Typically, the franchisee is
his or her own boss on a daily basis. The
franchisor also has a say in the business. For
instance, the franchisor is usually responsible
for quality control and for maintaining a
uniform image among all franchisees. If the
quality is not up to par, the franchisor may
direct the franchisee to make
changes.
Is a Lawyer Necessary?
It is highly advisable to consult a
lawyer. A franchise agreement is a highly
technical business document that can have
serious financial consequences. The laws
regarding franchising vary from state to state,
and you do not want to end up with an invalid
agreement or unintended liabilities.
Franchising Checklist
Before entering into a franchise
agreement, you should consult a lawyer to be
sure that you understand what your
responsibilities are.
As a potential franchisee, you, along with your lawyer, you should:
- Thoroughly review the financial
disclosure and other documents relating to the
franchisor and the business
- Understand the franchise fee that you
will have to pay and the payment schedule
- Review state law requirements, if any,
regarding franchise advertising
- Familiarize yourself with federal and any
state law regulations governing the franchise
relationship
- Learn about your competition and the
legal issues dealing with the handling of
competitive activities.
Before signing the franchise agreement, you should know what it says regarding certain key issues, including:
- Your right to have the only franchise
within a certain territory
- Its term, termination and renewal
- Any limitations on your right to sell the
franchise
- Costs and procedures for terminating the
agreement
- Any restrictions on your right to operate
a competing business when the franchise
agreement terminates
- Your liability, if any, if the franchise
does not make its projected profits.
Return to Table of Contents
for this guide | Return
to index of all guides | Return to the top of this page
While the advantages and disadvantages of
each type of business structure are readily
identified, choosing the most appropriate for
your business may be a somewhat thorny issue.
Many small business owners reflexively--and
often wrongfully--assume that the corporate form
is best for them simply because of the liability
protection it offers. Before incurring
incorporation and other expenses, though, you
should consider several factors. First, forming
a corporation does not necessarily guarantee
protection from personal liability. For example,
you may be asked to give a personal guarantee on
a commercial lease entered into by your
corporation.
Also, there is a legal concept known as
piercing the corporate veil. If your corporation
is substantially undercapitalized, or if you
consistently fail to observe corporate
formalities (such as keeping your personal
assets separate from those of the corporation),
a creditor may ask a court to rule that you and
the corporation are essentially one and the
same. The court could pierce the corporate veil,
and your personal assets could be used to
satisfy the creditor's claim.
Certain state law provisions may also
result in personal liability even if your
business is incorporated. In New York, for
example, the top ten shareholders of a closely
held corporation are automatically personally
responsible for the wages and certain other
benefits owed to employees.
Finally, you should investigate whether
insurance can adequately cover your risk of
personal liability. Depending on the nature of
your business, reasonably priced insurance --
rather than incorporation -- may offer enough
protection and save you from additional expense
and administrative burdens.
In choosing a corporate structure you
should also take tax considerations into
account. If you are like most small business
owners, chances are that you will lose money
during your first few years of operations. From
the tax standpoint alone, then, there may be no
advantage to incorporating -- at least during
the years in which you are posting losses.
For the "start-up" small business in
particular, the driving consideration for
determining the appropriate business structure
probably remains the question of liability. If
your business puts human life at risk (for
example, you run a bike touring company), or you
have substantial contracts with outside vendors,
you would probably should incorporate and to
make sure that you run a "tight corporate ship"
even if you are adequately
insured.
|