|
When you
truly understand the difference between and idea
and an invention, you will have overcome one of
the major impediments to the success of
independent inventors. An idea is just a problem
statement. An invention is a solution to that
problem. Ideas aren't patentable.
Inventions are.
An Example:
Assume
that artificial Christmas trees didn't exist,
and you've come up with the idea that an
artificial Christmas tree might sell. People
wouldn't have to go shopping for a new tree each
year, they wouldn't have to keep it watered or
clean up fallen needles, and they wouldn't have
the problems of disposing of it. It would save
trees and relieve landfill clogging, etc., etc.
You feel this is a great idea but you're afraid
someone will steal it. So you rush to a patent
attorney, if you're lucky enough to miss the
ubiquitous "Inventions Wanted" ads.
The attorney, however, will
inform you that you can't patent the idea of an
artificial Christmas tree. You have to "reduce
it to practice." What (and all) you can patent
is an implementation of it; i.e., a design and
construction that you work out. So you go back
and play around with different designs (in real
or on paper) and finally come up with something
that looks and feels pretty good to
you.
You rush back to the
attorney, he does a patent search and tells you
it's "patentable." You tell him to go ahead, he
gets a patent application filed, and you breathe
a sigh of relief. Now you're "protected" and
your fortunes made.
Well, you
have a surprise coming! It's almost certain
you've blown the time and money you've invested.
Paranoia got in the way of common sense, and in
your fear of someone "stealing" your idea (and
you, thereby, losing you your golden
opportunity), you've taken actions (and adopted
a mind set) that virtually guarantees your loss
of that opportunity. You minimized some legal
risk, but at the cost of maximizing your
business risk. That's a bad tradeoff.
A Better
Approach?
Recognize
the difference between an invention and an idea,
and quit trying to protect ideas. In the case of
your artificial Christmas tree, it's not your
idea that may be salable or licensable, it's
your implementation
of that idea.
You need
to come up with a "winning" design. Unless
you're extraordinarily skilled (or lucky), you
need outside input to have any chance of doing
so. How do you find that input? Simply talk to
potential customers about the idea and listen to
what they have to say. But won't people steal
your idea and go develop their own? Yes, there's
a risk. But let's look at that risk in the harsh
light of reality.
First, most people won't
share your enthusiasm for your idea even if it's
a good one. People mentally resist change. They
cling to the status quo. The overwhelming
majority of people exposed to your idea will
reject it out-of-hand. "It would ruin the spirit
of Christmas," "I certainly wouldn't have
one in my house," etc. More than likely, your
problem will be finding anyone who'll take your
idea seriously enough to offer the input you
need.
Second,
the few people who may pick up on it and think
it's a good idea are too busy to develop it
themselves. There's a great deal of work
required to go from an idea to a good design.
They have their own priorities they're working
on. Even if they think it's a promising idea and
want to be involved, why would they go charging
off to do it them self or hire it done, when
they have you chomping at the bit to do it for
free? To save a 5 percent royalty? I don't think
so!
Let's look
at what you lost in your first approach of
rushing off to the patent attorney and what you
gain in this new approach.
In your
first approach, after your attorney told you you
needed a design, you went home and designed
something. You probably recognized that its
"realism" was important. So you played around
with materials for the trunk and branches and
bristles and came up with something that looked
pretty "real" and that's what you patented. In
the new approach, hopefully some of your
contacts will talk with you.
Some of the first things
you'll hear are: "This is a big, bulky item. How
would you ship it? How would a store stock it?
In fact, how would the user store it during the
off-season?" Oops! Maybe it has to be
collapsible. Back to the drawing board, and you
work out a design in which the branches are
removable, and the user has to do a little
assembly. You may also work out some methods for
making the assembly a little easier and a little
more foolproof. And, you may have to change some
of your materials; e.g., use a springier
material in your bristles so they'll pop back
into shape after being crushed in the
box.
Now that
you've got an answer to that problem, back to
your contacts. Even with a verbal description,
they're not interested in how you did it -- only
with the end result. Now you may hear questions
like "Is it safe?" "Will it burn if there's an
electrical short?" "How about a glass ornament
that the sun shines through?" Wow! If I
make this thing inflammable, I've really got
something! Back to the drawing board, some
material changes, back to the contacts.
You get
the idea. After you've cycled through your
contacts (i.e., anyone who'll seriously
listen) and satisfied their criticisms, or as
many as you're able, that's the time you may
want to talk with a patent attorney.
And what
do you want to talk to him about patenting? The
features that provide the user benefits: The
removable branches, the springy bristles, the
inflammability, etc. Keep in mind that through
this whole process, you haven't had to disclose
how you did anything, only the end result. For
example, the "idea" of removable branches is not
patentable. How you made them removable without
compromising ease of assembly, sturdiness, etc.,
may be patentable.
Now, which of these two
approaches is more likely to result in a salable
or licensable product? If you've grasped the
difference between an idea and an invention, you
have the answer.
Return to
Table of Contents for this guide
| Return to
index of all guides | Return to the
top of this page
Think you
have a great idea for a new product or service?
You're not alone. Every year, tens of thousands
of people try to develop their ideas and
commercially market them.
Some people try to sell
their idea or invention to a manufacturer that
would market it and pay royalties. But finding a
company to do that can be overwhelming. As an
alternative, others use the services of an
invention or patent promotion firm. Indeed, many
inventors pay thousands of dollars to firms that
promise to evaluate, develop, patent, and market
inventions... and then do little or nothing for
their fees.
Unscrupulous promoters take
advantage of an inventor's enthusiasm for a new
product or service. They not only urge inventors
to patent their ideas or invention, but they
also make false and exaggerated claims about the
market potential of the invention. The facts
are: few inventions ever make it to the
marketplace; and getting a patent doesn't
necessarily increase the chances of commercial
success.
There's
great satisfaction in developing a new product
or service and in getting a patent. But when it
comes to determining market potential, inventors
should proceed with caution as they try to avoid
falling for the sweet-sounding promises of a
fraudulent promotion firm.
Using Patent or Invention
Promotion Firms
Advertisements for invention
promotion firms are on television, radio and the
Internet, and in newspapers and magazines. These
ads target independent inventors with offers of
free information on how to patent and market
their inventions. Often, however, the
information is about the promoter.
If you respond to the
ad(s) which may urge you to call a toll-free
number(s) you may hear back from a salesperson
who will ask for a sketch of the invention and
information about your idea and you. As an
inducement, a firm may offer to do a free
preliminary review of your invention.
Some invention promotion
firms may claim to know or have special access
to manufacturers who are likely to be interested
in licensing your invention. In addition, some
firms may claim to represent manufacturers on
the lookout for new product ideas. Ask for proof
before you sign a contract with any invention
promotion firm that claims special relationships
with manufacturers.
After giving your invention
a preliminary review, a firm might tell you it
needs to do a market evaluation of your
idea(s) for a fee that can be several hundred
dollars. Many questionable firms don't do any
genuine research or market evaluations. The
"research" is bogus, and the "positive" reports
are mass-produced in an effort to sell clients
on additional invention promotion and marketing
services. Fraudulent invention promotion firms
don't offer an honest appraisal of the merit,
technical feasibility, or market potential of an
invention.
Some invention promotion
firms also may offer a contract in which they
agree to help you market and license your
invention to manufacturers. Unscrupulous
promoters may require you to pay a fee of
several thousand dollars in advance. Reputable
licensing agents usually don't rely on large
advance fees. Rather, they depend on royalties
from the successful licensing of client
inventions. How can they make money when so few
inventions achieve commercial success?
They're choosy about which
ideas or inventions they pursue. If a firm is
enthusiastic about the market potential of your
idea(s) but charges you a fee in advance, take
your business elsewhere.
Heads Up
If you're
interested in working with an invention
promotion firm, here's information that can help
you avoid making a costly mistake. Many
fraudulent invention promotion firms offer
inventors two services in a two-step process:
one involves a research report or market
evaluation of your idea that can cost you
hundreds of dollars. The other involves
patenting or marketing and licensing services,
which can cost you several thousand dollars.
Early in your discussion with a promotion firm,
ask for the total cost of its services, from the
"research" about your invention through the
marketing and licensing. Walk away if the
salesperson hesitates to answer.
Many
fraudulent companies offer to provide invention
assistance or marketing services in exchange for
advance fees that can range from $5,000 to
$10,000. Reputable licensing agents rarely rely
on large upfront fees.
Unscrupulous invention
promotion firms tell all inventors that their
ideas are among the relative few that have
market potential. The truth is that most ideas
don't make any money.
Many
questionable invention promotion firms claim to
have a great record licensing their clients'
inventions successfully. Ask the firm to
disclose its success rate, as well as the names
and telephone numbers of their recent clients.
Success rates show the number of clients who
made more money from their inventions than they
paid to the firm. Check the references. In
several states, disclosing the success rate is
the law.
Ask an
invention promotion firm for its rejection
rate & the percentage of all ideas or inventions
that the invention promotion firm finds
unacceptable. Legitimate firms generally have
high rejection rates.
Fraudulent invention
promotion firms may promise to register your
idea with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office's
Disclosure Document Program. Many scam artists
charge high fees to do this. The cost of filing
a disclosure document in the PTO is $10.
The
disclosure is accepted as evidence of the date
of conception of the invention, but it doesn't
offer patent protection. Unscrupulous firms
often promise that they will exhibit your idea
at tradeshows. Most invention promotion scam
artists don't go to these tradeshows; much less
market your idea effectively.
Many
unscrupulous firms agree in their contracts to
identify manufacturers by coding your idea with
the U.S. Bureau of Standard Industrial Code
(SIC). Lists of manufacturers that come from
classifying your idea with the SIC usually are
of limited value.
Common Sense
Tips
Contracting for the services
of an invention promotion firm is no different
from making many other major purchases. Apply
the same common sense. Question claims and
assurances that your invention will make money.
No one can guarantee your invention's success.
Investigate the company before you make any
commitment. Call the Better Business Bureau, the
consumer protection agency, and the Attorney
General in your city or state, and in the city
or state where the company is headquartered to
find out if there are any unresolved consumer
complaints about the firm.
Make sure
your contract contains all the terms you agreed
to both verbal and written before you sign. If
possible, ask an attorney to review the
agreement. Remember that once a dishonest
company has your money, it's likely you'll never
get it back.
For More
Information
The Patent and Trademark
Office offers information about patents,
trademarks, and copyrights. Write to the U.S.
Department of Commerce, Patent and Trademark
Office, Washington, D.C. 20231; call toll-free
at 1-800-PTO-9199. For more information about
the Disclosure Document Program, call
703-308-4357. In addition, every state has a
Patent and Trademark Depository Library that
maintains collections of current and previously
issued patents and Patent and Trademark
reference materials.
The FTC
works for the consumer to prevent fraudulent,
deceptive and unfair business practices in the
marketplace and to provide information to help
consumers spot, stop and avoid them. To file a
complaint, or to get free information on any of
150 consumer topics, call toll-free,
1-877-FTC-HELP (1-877-382-4357), or use the
online complaint form
. The FTC enters Internet,
telemarketing, and other fraud-related
complaints into Consumer Sentinel, a secure,
online database available to hundreds of civil
and criminal law enforcement agencies worldwide.
Return to
Table of Contents for this guide
| Return to
index of all guides | Return to the
top of this page
As an individual in the
early idea stages, are you experiencing
excitement and frustration right now? On the one
hand, are you seeing the rewards and potential
of your idea while being simultaneously plagued
by a multitude of confusing questions about how
to start, who to go to, who to trust, how much
it will cost, and whether your idea is even
worth pursuing? If so, you're not
alone.
In more
than a decade of guiding thousands of
innovator's, we've found that most people with
new ideas have little or no experience in
commercializing a product and usually work at a
full-time job. So it's very understandable that
you may not have the knowledge, time or
resources to develop and launch your new
product. Our goal at DreamsToMarket.com, is to
educate you about what you need to do, and to
help increase the odds that your products will
make it to market.
Your First
Priority
Our belief
is that education should be your first priority
in developing your new idea. After all, do
doctors simply decide to practice medicine and
just "do it?" Do lawyers become lawyers
overnight? Of course not. These are specialized
fields that require years of study and practice
and a high cost for the education.
Most of us know that with
specialization comes higher financial rewards.
We believe that it's the same with innovating.
Yet we've found that most people just jump right
in, immediately go get a patent or build an
expensive prototype, or invest into a firm they
think will do it all for them. By the way,
there's no such thing.
Inventing
is not a "get rich quick" business. Those who
know this realize that only a small percentage
of inventors even make it all the way through
the process. We believe that this is because
most people think that they'll be an overnight
success and don't do first things first. As a
result, they end up taking the wrong paths.
We've heard sad stories of
inventors who didn't do "first things first" and
have spent thousands of dollars (average
$3-10,000) on a patent, in addition to the costs
of prototypes, molds, and manufacturing runs
(average $20-100,000); only to realize, after
the fact, that their product didn't have the
expected market value or potential they
initially thought it had.
Many of these inventors have
ended up stuck with unsold products in every
nook and cranny of their garage, attic, or
basement because even the liquidators (who
normally pay pennies on the dollar) wouldn't buy
their stock. Just as sad, we've spoken with many
people with ideas who ended up with the scam
companies who told them what they wanted to
hear, took all their money and let their idea
die, as well as killed the individual's spirit
of inventing.
The bottom
line is that ultimately nobody can guarantee you
success - even WITH enough education. There are
just too many factors and variables involved in
launching a new product. The marketplace will be
the final judge for your product.
We believe, however, that
your odds of succeeding will greatly increase
with a rock-solid foundation of knowledge upon
which to build. With the educated path, the
worst-case scenario (if you were to find out
that your idea is a no-go) would be that you
ended up spending only the necessary and minimum
amount of money along with your sweat equity. We
believe this isn't a loss, because you'll be
able to utilize all these skills and knowledge
with your next great idea...and the next...and
the next.
Return to
Table of Contents for this guide
| Return to
index of all guides | Return to the
top of this page
The
"Inventor's Tool Kit" is a set of four key
documents that, when used properly, provides you
with solid protection during the early stages of
the invention process.
The
kit includes:
- The
Disclosure Document, which establishes your
legal date of conception.
- The
Confidentiality Agreement, which prevents others
from claiming ownership in your invention and
maintains secrecy.
- The Work
Agreement, which assures your ownership of any
contributions to your invention that are
provided by others.
- The
License Agreement, which assures your receipt of
royalties from those that benefit from your
patent rights.
Let's
take a closer look at these
documents.
The
Disclosure Document (DD) establishes
ownership because, under U. S. law, patent
rights legally belong to the first inventor
unless the idea is abandoned. To be effective,
however, the DD must clearly teach how to make
and use the invention, and it must be signed and
witnessed. It should be in a permanently-bound
book with numbered pages. And, it must be
followed up with provable, diligent reduction to
practice.
The
Confidentiality Agreement (CA) may be the
most important document of all. Its use allows
you to start the marketability and patentability
discovery processes without opening the door to
claims of public disclosure, which might bar
patentability here or abroad. The CA must
be referenced to the DD so that no
misunderstanding can arise as to what the pledge
of confidence is about.
The CA
should identify what the intended purpose of the
confidential disclosure is, and it should state
that the disclosed is released from the
agreement in the following circumstances: if the
invention comes into the public domain, if the
invention is already known by disclosed, if the
invention is already known by others, and if the
invention has not, or is not, treated by the
inventor as confidential material in dealings
with others.
The
Work Agreement (WA) is important when you
obtain outside help. Such help might be in
reduction to practice, artistic design,
improvements in concept or construction, etc.
The WA is very important because, by law, ALL
true inventors must be specified in your US
patent application. If a contractor has
contributed to the invention and you elect to
legally claim his/her improvements in your
patent application, the contractor must be
treated as a co-inventor in your application.
The WA
allows the contractor to legally be bound to
transfer his/her rights in the application to
the inventor. Contractor compensation may be
salary, fixed contract price or a percent of the
first profits, but should not be a percent of
ownership in the patents, which carry some of
the contractor's inventive contribution. The WA
legally binds the contractor to transfer his or
her rights in any patents for the compensation
paid for his or her work, even if the
compensation occurs in the future, i.e., option
rights, etc. Rights transferred are for US and
foreign patents and any continuations,
divisions, and reissues. The contractor is
also obliged to help perfect your patents.
The
License Agreement (LA) may be the most
complex agreement in law. Please don't try to
negotiate such an agreement without professional
help. The patent or pending patent should be
clearly identified as well as the names,
addresses and entity status of each of the
parties. The LA gives rights of making, using,
and/or selling for products protected under law
by the patent grants or potential patent grants.
Usually an "upfront" fee is stipulated, but in
many agreements the licensee considers his
investment of time and money in tooling and
initial market rollout to be an adequate initial
investment. In this case, the inventor must
include controls in the LA that will enable
him/her to back out of the agreement if certain
actions are not taken on schedule.
Considerations of
exclusivity, duration, disputes, termination,
assignability, sublicensing, patent right
defense, improvements to the invention by the
inventor or by the licensee, marking of products
that are protected under the patents, trademark
usage and control, foreign sales and patent
protection, are just a few of the important
issues to be negotiated. Having
experience, so as to be able to assert knowledge
of typical agreements in forcing contractual
terms to meet your needs, is essential in
striking a deal. Some of the more important
issues are the royalty rate, minimum royalty
amount, when it is to be paid and to whom it
will be paid.
The latter is important with
respect to income tax considerations. The
Inventor's Tool Kit provides the basic legal
tools necessary to the maintenance of rights in
bringing a new product idea to
market. Familiarity with these four
documents enables anyone to proceed with greater
confidence in selecting professionals to help,
and in making the important early decisions
necessary for business success with inventive
ideas. To purchase the inventor's
tool kit click here.
Return to
Table of Contents for this guide
| Return to
index of all guides | Return to the
top of this page
Innovation
cannot be thought of as a project or single
development. Rather, it must be viewed as a
critical and ongoing process within
organizations.
Today,
every company has to continuously improve,
extend and innovate. American businesses, with
few exceptions, seem to believe that innovation
is a "flash of genius," not a systematic,
organized, rigorous discipline. But, without a
well-conceived innovation strategy, we believe
companies will lack direction and ultimately
lose their competitiveness.
The Innovation Process
Starts With Planning
The fact is that planning
for the future is difficult, unpredictable, and
more important than ever. Planning for the
future is imperative because so much is changing
so fast, and the future will look nothing like
the present.
Innovation Management Can
Craft a Strategy for the Future
Today, the
innovations of many companies are propelled by
management desires, internal capabilities or
channel demands. These innovations sometimes
succeed because they have vision and meet
defined strategic goals -- and sometimes fail
because they do not. For the future, building
successful innovations will be even more
demanding, with little room for compromise. New
innovations must meet the needs of customers
first while also satisfying management,
providing a good business proposition for the
company, and using feasible and affordable
technology.
The
operating environment, yesterday and
today:
Yesterday
- Slow
product and service introduction
- Satisfied
with me-too products
- Traditional sales force
Today
- Constant
flow of new products and services
- Strong
need for differentiation
- Consulting
personnel
- Personal
computer e-commerce
- Gaining
share
- Creating
loyal customers
What will
tomorrow bring? More unknowns, but our site
enables you to continuously adapt to change and
surprise. This results in your ability to focus
skills and capabilities to achieve sustainable
value creation and competitive advantage.
The Need for "Front-end"
development
Most
companies focus on the "back-end" by improving
time-to-market, time-to-profits, reducing
development waste and increasing success
rates. While this is important, we believe
that focusing on "front-end" development creates
winning, sustainable strategies.
The
DreamsToMarket.com site builds on: (1) anticipating
customer needs, (2) identifying the best new
opportunities, (3) focusing attention on
differentiation, (4) getting ahead of new
technologies, and (5) knowing when to create new
product and technology platforms.
Building a Defined
Process
Innovation
Management can help by creating innovative
strategies including:
- Analyzing
the current situation Identifying opportunities
- Determining innovation
strategies
- Building
internal skills
- Training
- Optimizing
understanding
- Creating a
cross-functional approach
- Building
the appropriate development process
- Managing
the process
- Bringing
opportunities to market
Return to
Table of Contents for this guide
| Return to
index of all guides | Return to the
top of this page
The "Inventors Log
Book" is a very inexpensive process, YET
POSSIBLY YOUR MOST VALUABLE TOOL IN THE
PROTECTION OF YOUR NEW IDEA.
Why? Because the patent
system in the United States rewards the "first
person" that invents a new product. Therefore,
even if somebody else files a patent on the same
idea before you do, if you can prove that you
were the first person that invented the product
and you have the proper records of your ongoing
work, the patent would be awarded to you. The
key is that you have to prove that you conceived
and invented the product first.
So, as
soon as the "lightning" strikes, begin a daily
journal, diary-style, to keep track of your
idea(s). This will help you establish a date of
"conception." If two inventors have been
developing the same idea or if someone tries to
take your idea, it will be the one who has the
most dated and detailed notes and sketches who
will almost always win the legal battle.
To do this, you need dated
records showing any and all corrections and
revisions, receipts for purchases of any
materials used to make sample prototypes,
records of visits with patent attorneys or other
professionals, etc. And, that's where the "log
book" comes in. There's a special way to
do this. Make sure your idea is well documented
by following these easy guidelines.
Type of
Notebook
You will need a stitched or
bound notebook. "Official" invention logbooks
cost between $10-30 because they're hardbound,
larger, and include preprinted numbered pages
with specially designed grids and lines for your
notations and required signatures. They're the
easiest to use, however.
If you're
on a budget, you can purchase a "Mead
Composition"-type notebook, which costs under $5
and is available at most office supply stores.
If you have an Office Depot or Staples office
supply store near you, they usually sell a pack
of two or three for under $4. If you purchase
one of these types of notebooks, be sure to
immediately number all of the pages on both the
front and back of each page. An accountant's
record keeping-type book can also be used, and
they are available at office supply stores or
even drug stores like Thrifty.
Remember that the purpose of
the logbook is to have a chronological record of
all your work related to your invention. A
stitched or bound notebook makes it impossible
to tear out or add pages without detection, and
is the only type of notebook that will work in
court. Therefore, spiral notebooks will not
work. 3-ring binders with loose-leaf sheets will
not work either, nor tablets that are glued
together; i.e. legal pads
TIP: If you have more than
one idea that you will be working on
simultaneously, we recommend that you use one
logbook per idea.
What To
Include
The
logbook is a very detailed diary of your
progress. Write down everything you do, or
think, that is related to your invention in your
logbook - including any library research,
supplies you buy to make a model or sample,
improvements, design changes, any quotes from
manufacturers, and even mentioning it to
someone. When you test your idea, include both
positive and negative results. Include diagrams
and layouts, any special procedures, etc.
Each time you write new or
additional information in your logbook, it is
considered an "entry." Each entry should a date
and time. Each entry should be self-explanatory
which means that anyone reading it should be
able to understand it without any assistance or
explanations. Staple or tape any receipts,
bills, or paperwork to the pages.
TIP: If
you have had your idea for some time and have
not been documenting any of your work to date,
we recommend you backtrack as far back as you
can remember and include when you got the idea,
when you started working on it, what you have
done to date and any specifics you can recall.
Look at old check stubs and receipts to help you
relate exact dates. For example, if you
purchased any supplies for your invention,
you'll easily recognize the receipt noting the
date you purchased it as well as the store name.
Then enter these details and receipts in your
logbook as evidence.
Format for Each
Entry
A good format to begin your
logbook and initially describe your invention is
to answer the following questions in sequential
order:
- What is
the problem I am trying to solve?
- What is
currently available to solve this problem?
- What is my
solution and why is it better?
Once you have described your
invention, begin by answering the following
questions about "future action steps:"
- What
action needs to be taken next on this project?
- When does
this need to be completed by?
- What date
do I need to follow-up and check my progress?
Then be sure to mark your
calendar with these deadlines so that you can
make sure you are continuously working on your
invention and are conducting the "due-diligence"
requirements of the patent office.
Important Due-Diligence
Requirements
In order to be granted a
patent, an invention must be worked on
continuously and persistently. This is known as
the requirement of "diligence in completing the
invention" or "reduction to practice" under the
US patent laws. If you stop working on your
invention for several months or in some cases
even weeks without any progress, you may
jeopardize your rights to obtain a
patent.
After you
have completed your action steps, answer the
following question in your logbook: What action
did I take since my last entry? Remember
to be very detailed by also answering "When did
I do it, where did I do it, why did I do it, who
did I do it with? And list any results. Then, go
back to "future action steps" questions listed
above. It's a continual process of planning,
taking action, following up and then repeating
the process.
Some Rules to
Follow
You might
be tempted to use a pencil so you can erase and
make corrections, but because the purpose of the
logbook is for proof that the ideas are
originally yours, be sure to use ink that can't be
erased and modified by anyone. For this same
reason, you're not supposed to cross out any
mistakes.
In the case of drawings, we
recommend that you practice on scratch
paper and transfer the corrected versions of
sketches or drawings to the logbook - making
detailed notations about what's different from
the previous drawing.
Be
sure not to rip out or add any pages. It is
probably best to start every new entry on a new
page in order to make it neater and easier to
find your entries later. Therefore if your entry
ends in the middle of a page, draw a large "X"
on any empty spaces or blank pages, and start
your next entry on the next page. Be sure to
always draw a large "X" on any empty spaces or
blank pages.
Witnesses
At the end of each entry,
sign and date the page. Also write in the
following short paragraph: "I have witnessed and
understand this idea. I agree to keep this
disclosure confidential" and have two
unrelated "witnesses" (who are not involved
in the development of your invention) print
their names, sign and date it. Official logbooks
have this paragraph preprinted on every
page.
Notarize Your
Entries
Then have
the entry "notarized." Find a notary public near
you by looking in the phone book under the
category of "Notary Public." These
individuals serve as legal witnesses who will
provide you with a special seal as evidence that
they witnessed your documentation on the
specific date. They will also keep a record on
file. The price of each notarization may range
from $10-20.
You might check whether your
bank still provides this service. Most banks
used to have a public notary on hand as a
convenience to their customers, but over the
past decade many have eliminated this service.
For economical reasons, you may want to notarize
several entries in your logbook all at once
approximately every three to four weeks instead
of after every single entry. This will help you
keep your costs down, and will also be less time
consuming. Naturally, if you have specific
questions on the legal aspects of any steps of
this process, it may be wise to directly consult
with a patent attorney for proper legal
advice.
TIP: If
you're a real detailed individual and would like
more extensive information about properly
filling out an inventor's logbook, there is an
entire book on this subject titled "Inventors
Notebook" by Fred Grissom/David Pressman which
is a complete guide to documenting your idea. It
is available on our Products page.
Return to
Table of Contents for this guide
| Return to
index of all guides |
Return to the top of this page
You can digitally
fingerprint, time stamp and register any size or
type of digital file instantly online through a
web site called Firstuse.com.
By
registering your records, you have developed a
third party record proof of the date of idea
conception - if you register at the time you
develop new ideas. Since the United States is a
"First To Invent" country, the earlier
conception date of a new invention prevails over
the earlier patent filing date.
Firstuse.com's Registry is
not just for recording inventions. Artists,
musicians, writers, attorneys, technology
managers and more use the registry to record
(date/time stamp) important contracts, original
works and other time-sensitive documents of any
kind. Also, once a document has been registered,
you can include the registration proof logo on
any new copies of the document, alerting those
who receive the document that it has been third
party registered.
Instant, Online
Registry
Keeping a solid, verifiable
digital recording trail be a critical link to
maintaining ownership or earlier-date
positioning on intellectual property.
You can register your
intellectual property documents confidentially,
24 hours a day through their secure Internet
connection. Use the Registry to record progress.
Then, when you're ready, file your:
- Patent
Office Document Disclosure (DD)
- Provisional Patent
Application (PPA)
- Trademark
Application
- Copyright
Application
Your use
of the Registry does
not replace your requirement to file Patent,
Trademark and/or Copyright applications with the
United States Patent and Trademark Office,
United States Copyright Office, or any
applicable foreign patent, trademark or
copyright offices in countries where you seek
intellectual property protection. To protect
your rights to your intellectual property, you
must file the necessary applications with the
Patent or Copyright Offices.
How does the Digital
Fingerprinting/Time Stamp Registry work?
WHAT TO REGISTER:
- Daily log
entries (Electronic Witness)
- Research
notes and findings
- Drafts of
diagrams, drawings, and narratives
- Final
diagrams, drawings and narratives
- Drafts of
conceptual diagrams, drawings, and notes
- Drafts of
designs
- Contemporaneous conversation
notes with others
- Final
diagrams or designs
- Nondisclosure agreements
- Filings
with Patent Office and others
Note: Firstuse.com
registration enables you to create a
tamperproof, time-sealed audit trail of your
work to help strengthen Patent claims. It is NOT
a substitute for a Patent.
Storage
To achieve
true confidentiality and security, Firstuse.com
receives a digital fingerprint of your file, not
the file itself. However, to verify files in the
future, you must have an unaltered copy of the
registered file. You can store the file yourself
or use a Firstuse.com's Authorized Storage
Partner.
IMPORTANT: Please Read, "How
to Preserve Files" Before Registering
Files!
Verification
Your
registrations can be verified instantly,
worldwide, by anyone who has the original file
or an exact copy of the file you registered.
Give out only the information you want to third
parties. Enable an unlimited amount of third
parties to verify. Complete simple one-step
verification process in seconds.
Each Firstuse.com
Verification Contains:
- Your Name
- Organization
- File Name
- Digital
Fingerprint
- Digital
Timestamp
- Unique
File Number
- Preserving
Files for Future Verification
Important steps to follow
after registration
You must
keep an unchanged original or perfect copy of
your file. Create a folder on your hard drive
and drop the original file registered with
firstuse.com into that folder. Do not open and
"resave" a file after registration. Make changes
to a working copy only. Back up important files
frequently to a zip or floppy disk.
Make all
files registered with Firstuse.com "read only"
to help prevent alteration. This may be
accomplished by right clicking on a file,
selecting "properties" and then selecting "read
only". Consult your computer advisor for more
information on preserving files in "read only"
form.
IMPORTANT: you must maintain
the original file.
Firstuse.com never sees your
file
One of the main benefits of
using Firstuse.com is 100% confidentiality,
guaranteed. Firstuse.com can help prove what you
registered, when you registered it, and that the
file has never been altered since registration,
but they claim to never actually see your file.
Instead, Firstuse.com remains neutral as a
trusted third party by registering a
time-stamped digital fingerprint of your
file. Please also read their Legal
Notices.
The reason for special
handling of a Registered File
The byte
structure (underlying digital arrangement) of a
registered file must not change or it will not
fingerprint the same as it did originally and,
therefore, Firstuse.com will not be able to
verify it. Following the rules above will help
to preserve the file's byte structure.
Firstuse.com is a
confidential registry. The registry does not
read nor does it see the file you are
registering. Rather, through a technology known
as "digital fingerprinting" or "hashing,"
Firstuse.com creates and stores a Digital
Fingerprint (a random array of digits) of
your file in its Registry Database.
This
Digital Fingerprint is a unique identifier for
your file -- no two files can have the same
digital fingerprint. Because Firstuse.com only
stores a fingerprint of your file and not the
file itself, you must keep an unchanged version
of the file you registered in order for your
registration to be meaningful. At any time you
want to verify the file, you can use the
Firstuse.com Online Registry to do so.
The
Registry will re-fingerprint the file. If the
new fingerprint matches the fingerprint
Firstuse.com has on file in its database, then
the Registry can attest to the fact that the
file your are verifying is the exact file that
was originally registered and the precise time
and date the file was registered.
Preserving Your File for
Future Verification
Verifying a file is just as
simple as registering a file. You'll simply
visit the Registry again, browse your hard drive
or floppy disk, and re-fingerprint the original
or unaltered copy of the file you previously
registered.
If the new fingerprint
matches the fingerprint Firstuse.com has in its
database, then the Registry will display your
registration certificate, attesting to who
registered the file, the precise contents of the
previously registered file, that the file was
registered at a precise time and date and that
the file has never been altered.
IMPORTANT: Read, "How to
Preserve Files" Before Registering Files!
Registration
You can
instantly register a file simply by selecting
the file from your computer. Register any size
or type file (text, graphic, spreadsheet,
database, audio, video, and scan). Complete
simple two-step registration process in seconds.
Each
Firstuse.com Registration
Includes:
- Digital
Fingerprint
- Digital
Timestamp
- Secure
Storage Options
- Worldwide
Verification
- Registration Tracking
- True
Confidentiality
Return to
Table of Contents for this guide
| Return to
index of all guides | Return to the
top of this page
The "Nondisclosure
Agreement" sounds confusingly similar to the US
Patent & Trademark Office's
"Disclosure Document Program." Yet they are
completely different and unrelated.
A
Nondisclosure Agreement (also known as a
"Confidentiality Agreement") is used when
someone with an UN-patented idea for an
innovation shows it to another party and wants
that party to maintain as confidential any
information he or she learns about the product
as a result of the meeting.
The inventor draws up the
nondisclosure agreement and has the other party
sign that he/she will not disclose any of the
information to anyone else, and will not market
the idea or compete with you. In the very early
stages, we advise against indiscriminately
signing any Nondisclosure Agreements with any
product development companies, service
providers, investors, venture capitalists,
licensees, etc.
Keep the Details of your New
Innovation Secret at First
During the initial phases of
working on your new idea, you will generally not
need to reveal it to anyone. There is a way to
talk to people about your innovation without
telling them what it is or how it works! For
example, let's say your idea is "a toothbrush
with a long, curved handle which reaches further
into the mouth to get at hard-to-reach spots,
and extra long bristles made out of natural
materials to stimulate the gums." Instead of
revealing so much information, you can simply
say that you have developed a "new type of
toothbrush," or a "new teeth cleaning device" or
an "oral hygiene tool."
With these brief phrases,
you have provided a "general" picture of what
your product is, but it is so general and vague
that you have not given away any secret details
or features about your product or how it works.
If someone asks you more in-depth questions
after you have provided a short phrase such as
the one above, just explain that you are not
able to disclose any additional information
about the product at this time.
TIP: Keep the details of
your new product secret until you have at least
a patent pending, especially during the period
when you are not protected and are shopping for
services.
USE THE NONDISCLOSURE
(CONFIDENTIALITY) AGREEMENT SELECTIVELY WITH
ESSENTIAL SERVICE PROVIDERS WITH WHICH YOU HAVE
DECIDED TO WORK
The
Nondisclosure (Confidentiality) Agreement is
recommended as a tool for you to use once you
have progressed to the point where you have done
everything you can do on your own, and
absolutely need a professional to assist you
with the next phase.
For
example, you may need to hire a professional
prototype maker to help you develop a working
model of your product. Yet, while you are in the
initial phase of "shopping" for a prototype
maker, you do not need to reveal all of the
details about how your product works, nor is it
necessary to have the prototype maker sign a
Nondisclosure Agreement.
In the shopping phase, you
will want to find out what kind of experience
the company has, what successful clients they
have had, examples of their work, what their
fees are, how they charge, what forms of payment
they accept, how long a typical project takes
and other questions along those lines. They do
not need to know what your product is in order
to answer these basic questions for you. Some of
these companies may operate like a doctor's
office where they initially provide you with a
Nondisclosure Agreement to fill out while you
wait in the lobby.
In this case, fill out the
basic contact information and explain to the
receptionist that you cannot complete the entire
form. In other cases, the company may say that
they can't provide you with an accurate quote or
estimate without knowing what the product is.
This may be true, but you can still get a
general idea of the price range for a product
similar to yours - without revealing your
product. Explain that you understand their
concern, but that you are not ready to sign a
Nondisclosure Agreement yet, and cannot reveal
what your product is because you are in the
early stages.
In order to get a sample
quote; provide them with a similar product that
is already out on the market. For example, you
can ask them to give you a quote on making a
typical toothbrush prototype. This way, when you
have quotes from several companies on the same
product, you'll have a "general" idea of the
costs and can compare their advice and pricing.
In this way, if you have spoken with ten
prototype companies, you haven't given away the
full details of your product to all ten
companies - when in fact you'll only be
working with one.
Once you have shopped and
decided which company you are going to work
with, naturally you must reveal the details of
your idea and how it works in order for the
company (for example, a prototype maker) to do
its job. At this point, use the Nondisclosure
Agreement to protect yourself before any work is
started. In this way, you are using the
Nondisclosure Agreement "selectively" throughout
the period prior to applying for a
patent.
To recap,
the Nondisclosure Agreement should be used after
you have made the decision to work with a
certain company or individual who absolutely
needs to know how your product works in order to
perform their special craft. Working this way,
you'll narrow down the amount of people that
know about your product, and you will greatly
reduce the risk of someone stealing your idea.
What If a Company Refuses to
Sign a Nondisclosure Agreement?
If a company you selected
refuses to sign a Nondisclosure Agreement, you
will have to make a personal decision about
whether or not to work with the company.
Since you do not have any patent protection yet,
you'll need to assess whether you can take a
risk to work with this company.
If they won't sign a
Nondisclosure Agreement, it isn't necessarily a
sign that this company intends to steal your
idea. There may be valid reasons for not signing
Nondisclosure Agreements. For example, if you
already have a patent, there's no need for a
company to sign a Nondisclosure Agreement and
most companies will refuse to sign them, but at
this stage where you're patented, it's a valid
refusal.
The
company may have had a previous bad experience
where they signed a Nondisclosure Agreement and
ended up being unfairly sued, so they developed
a policy of not signing them in the future. If
the company happens to be the best in the
industry, it might be worth the risk to work
with them anyway.
On the
other hand, it might not. Don't jump to
conclusions one way or the other. Be sure to do
your research and ask them the specific reasons
why they won't sign one. So you need to take all
the specific circumstances into consideration,
and weigh the benefits as we |